This simply underscores the general stupidity of the majority of the American public.
What we initially saw in the Ray Rice case was the video of him dragging his wife (NOTE: She was at that time his fiancee – can you believe she married him afterward??) out of the elevator and his admission that he had hit her, which was why she was being dragged out — because he knocked her out cold — he’s lucky he didn’t kill her or cause brain damage. Not only did he get off light for it, his wife got nothing for her actions — well, at least she’s getting something now for them.
We didn’t need to see the 2nd video as it didn’t give us any new facts that SHOULD have changed the outcome of the punishment that SHOULD have been handed down to Ray Rice, but it did make a positive difference in that he’s now getting something closer to what he deserves, although once again, society has gone overboard, and on top of that, now Janay Rice is getting punished for HER complicity, albeit extremely harshly in my opinion, but hindsight is usually 20/20 & the public usually gets it all wrong anyway.
Her complicity? She’s the victim, right? Not completely if you know all the facts, which the new video allegedly clearly shows, and if you look closely in the old video, you can see it there also, and it was her actions that escalated the confrontation.
What I’m saying is, we knew A) Ray Rice hit his wife hard, and B) She was knocked out cold for a few minutes & was dragged out of the elevator by him (instead of picking her up). What does it matter if we actually SAW the punch?? It doesn’t matter — he got off lightly and that was that.
But this is what the airing of the 2nd video did:
1) It was a jolt to actually see it happening rather than imagining it happening or hearing about it — we felt more enraged because we saw it, but the act nor the facts of the case against HIM changed ; only our collective experience of it changed. The video ignited a new collective rage against Rice, but that rage should have been this strong BEFORE the video was aired — if it had been, he would have gotten something closer to a fair punishment instead of what he got first & what he just got handed down.
2) It rehashed the fact that Rice got off easy for this, and it made the NFL & the Ravens do what it should have done in the first place — give him a harsher sentence, only this time, instead of getting a half-season or a full season off without pay & mandatory education to reorient his thinking in how to deal with his anger, he’s now lost his job & is banned indefinitely from the NFL — the typical heavy-handed socio-politics of punishment in action. It was no problem for many people to say that a 2-game suspension was OK; now many of those same people are calling for his head on a platter, and that’s as wrong as the original punishment was. Draconian sentencing is better left for the Medieval Ages — we shouldn’t throw dirty people out with their bath water. These are human beings & they deserve a chance to pay for their punishment, hopefully get rehabilitated & have a chance to reenter society on the same terms that they left. This is one of the problems why our society is screwed up & why recidivism is high.
3) Let’s be fair — although Rice’s wife was a victim of his brutality, the video plainly shows she isn’t totally innocent — it shows her A) pushing Ray BEFORE she got into the elevator, and he doesn’t touch her in retaliation, and B) she SPITS on him once they get into the elevator, which started the physical altercation near the elevator control panel, then C) she approached Rice in attack mode after he slapped her and/or got in her face after SHE SPIT ON HIM as soon as they got into the elevator. That’s when he hit her. Wrong, yes, but she was wrong also — at least that’s what the police thought when they charged her.
The video doesn’t clearly show the spitting or the knockout punch. The surveillance camera was running at appx 3/fps in my estimation, whereas better cameras run 10x that speed, but you can tell he hit her nevertheless, and if you look closely, you can see she spit on him & the AP has confirmed this by their viewing of a better-quality video that hasn’t been made public yet. Janay isn’t a completely-innocent victim, although the reaction she got from him wasn’t right either & was far & above what she did.
However, she had no right to attack him any more than he had a right to hit her, and his hitting her wasn’t a self-defense right; he should have simply restrained her if he thought she was going to hit him, unless she possesses some sort of self-defense skills that we aren’t aware of, like maybe she’s a mentally-unbalanced Tae Kwon Do champion who gets physical when she gets enraged & he knew that & felt threatened, but I highly doubt that scenario. It’s easy for most people to say that she owed him payback if he hit her first, but the law doesn’t see it that way, and her pushing, splitting & approaching Ray in attack mode isn’t right, period. It doesn’t give her carte blanche to do as she pleases no more than him having the right to punch her.
Now flash forward to today — Rice & his wife are unemployed because of what happened between them. Once again, not trying to make excuses for Ray, but do you think Janay would have touched Ray before they got in the elevator or have spit on him or have moved toward him in attack mode in the elevator if she knew that it would cause not only the physical & legal problems they received, but also cause her husband to lose his job over the matter & jeopardize his entire career? That’s why she’s mad now in my opinion — he just lost at least $4 million & probably way more when this is all said & done, and she’s JUST AS COMPLICIT in this matter as he is — 2 wrongs don’t make a right, and if she had been in self-control, he probably wouldn’t have hit her. She’s also surely mad that people now know she spit on him & went after him before she was knocked out. Not an excuse again; just an observation & a reasonable conclusion to make. Going off half-cocked and excusing her actions & complicity is not truly objective.
Also note that Rice AND HIS WIFE were charged with Simple Assault, but the charges were raised against him to Aggravated Assault before the 2nd video came out (which was correct in my opinion) and the charges were completely dropped against her, which was very wrong in my opinion — the video clearly shows her complicity — moving toward a person and intending to strike them is clearly Simple Assault even if you don’t actually hit them. If you hit them, then you’ve got Battery, hence the term “Assault & Battery”. And spitting could be considered to be Simple Assault as well, especially if the person spitting were trying to communicate a disease or other sickness, which I know wasn’t the case here, but it isn’t something that should be overlooked, and she may think it’s perfectly fine to push, spit & attack people in the future because she got away with it legally.
Once again, because most people tend to stop reading the facts after they read a few things they disagree with, this is not an excuse for Ray Rice’s actions. This is simply to point out the 3 facts above that the 2nd video showed us, and it also shows how wrong the NFL & the Ravens got it in the 1st place, and it shows the societal & legal dichotomy present in that his wife doesn’t have to answer for her role in the argument because she got the worse of it, and now they’re both paying for it in the end with his termination. Letting people go easy for this type of behavior simply encourages it later — ask the families of Nicole Brown Simpson & Ron Goldman, assuming you believe that OJ killed them.
In closing, ruining this couple’s life over this matter is wrong. He should have gotten a fair punishment, which should have been a half-season or a full season, and she should have to legally answer for her actions just as he’s having to do.
You must be logged in to post a comment.